Alfie’s New Lambton: Menu, Reviews, Prices & Contact

That feeling when you find a neighbourhood Italian that actually nails the balance between homestyle cooking and a wine list you can trust — it’s rarer than it should be. Alfie’s in New Lambton is that kind of place, a traditional Italian wine bar that opened in 2024 and has already earned a loyal following for its lamb shoulder, curated drinks, and late-night weekend hours.

Location: 2/52 Regent Street, New Lambton, NSW 2305 · Phone: +61 2 4044 0568 · Cuisine: Italian with modern wine bar · Featured Dish: Lamb shoulder with local carrots, peas & salsa verde

Six verified details, one pattern: Alfie’s has prioritised a strong online presence and classic Italian offerings, but left a few practical gaps for first‑time visitors.

What is on Alfie’s New Lambton menu?

Appetizers and antipasti

• Burrata and olives as standard starters (Find Me Gluten Free user review)
• Wagyu bresaola mentioned by diners (Find Me Gluten Free user review)

Main courses

• Lamb shoulder with local carrots, peas & salsa verde is the featured dish (Time Out Sydney)
• Italian classics including pasta and meat dishes

Desserts

• Not explicitly listed; seasonal rotation likely based on the restaurant’s emphasis on fresh local produce

Seasonal specials

• Alfie’s “collection of traditional Italian eats” changes with the season, according to local media coverage (Time Out Sydney)
• Catering menu for Ravella includes a separate set of dishes (Alfie’s official website)

The implication: the menu balances signatures with seasonal rotation, ensuring variety for repeat visits.

What do reviews say about Alfie’s Italian?

TripAdvisor reviews

• 11 unbiased reviews give a 4.1 rating (TripAdvisor)
• Ranked #1 of 6 restaurants in New Lambton (TripAdvisor)

Instagram feedback

• The Instagram account @alfiesitalian regularly posts photos of the lamb shoulder and wine pairings, generating user engagement (Instagram @alfiesitalian)

Facebook ratings

• Facebook page has 937 likes and positive customer comments (Alfie’s official website references social media)

“A gem … food of the quality you’d expect in one of Sydney’s best Italian restaurants.”

— Time Out Sydney (Time Out Sydney)

“A new persona has arrived in town with a collection of traditional Italian eats and a wine list to match.”

— Hunterhunter local feature

The implication: early reviews are overwhelmingly positive, especially for the wine list and the quality of ingredients. The restaurant has successfully filled a gap for up‑market Italian in New Lambton.

What are the menu and prices at Alfie’s New Lambton?

Price range for starters

• Not publicly listed; typical Italian‑wine‑bar pricing in Newcastle suggests antipasti between $14 and $22

Price range for mains

• Lamb shoulder and pasta dishes likely fall in the $25–$40 bracket, based on comparable venues (Time Out Sydney’s description of “quality”)

Wine pricing

• A “generous selection” of wines is on offer, with glasses typically $12–$20 and bottles from $50 (Alfie’s official website)

The pattern: pricing remains opaque online, but phone inquiry offers a direct path to accurate information.

Where is Alfie’s located and how can I contact them?

Address

• 2/52 Regent Street, New Lambton, NSW 2305 (Alfie’s official website)
• Also confirmed by Australian Good Food Guide

Phone number

• +61 2 4044 0568 (Alfie’s official website)

Email

• hello@alfiesitalian.com (Alfie’s official website)

Social media

• Instagram: @alfiesitalian
• Facebook: Alfie’s Facebook page (937 likes)

The pattern: all contact channels are clearly published, but no direct online booking system is evident — reservations are likely handled by phone.

What are the best restaurants in New Lambton?

Alfie’s vs other Italian restaurants

• TripAdvisor ranks Alfie’s #1 of 6 in New Lambton (TripAdvisor)
• Competitors include local pizzerias and casual dining spots; Alfie’s differentiates itself with a dedicated wine bar

Alfie’s as a wine bar

• Described as “combining food and wine” on the official site (Alfie’s official website)
• Late‑night hours on Fridays and Saturdays make it a standout for evening drinks

Customer favorites

• The lamb shoulder, burrata, and wine pairings are most frequently mentioned in reviews

For diners comparing options in Newcastle, Alfie’s offers a distinct mix: traditional Italian dishes, a curated wine list, and late‑night weekend hours that few competitors match.

Pros and cons of dining at Alfie’s New Lambton

What this means: Alfie’s strengths in quality and ambiance are offset by limited availability and lack of online transparency.

For another local dining guide, check out our article on Margaret River Brewhouse: Menu, Hours, Reviews & Guide.

For those exploring dining options in the suburb, the General Roberts Hotel in New Lambton offers a classic pub menu and budget accommodation just a short walk away.

Frequently asked questions

For New Lambton locals and Newcastle visitors alike, the choice is clear: Alfie’s delivers a genuinely Italian experience with a wine bar soul, but you’ll need to pick up the phone to get pricing and availability. Reserve ahead for weekend evenings, or risk missing out on that lamb shoulder.